Hillcrest Cemetery Holds the 1914 Dead and Records That Disagree

Alberta Tribune
Alberta Tribune is an independent Alberta new media and opinion publication based in Calgary. This is the editorial desk byline, used for reporting and commentary produced...
5 Min Read
The western plot of the 1914 mine disaster graves in Old Hillcrest Cemetery, looking south, photographed in July 2017. Photo: Jeffery J. Nichols, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped.

Anyone who enters Old Hillcrest Cemetery from the south climbs a concrete stile set into a long fence strung with steel cable, wire and rail. The Canadian Register of Historic Places describes both as features of the site, along with the grave markers inside.

The cemetery covers 1.45 hectares on the eastern slope of Turtle Mountain, in the Crowsnest Pass. On June 19, 1914, an explosion in the Hillcrest mine killed 189 men, the worst mining disaster in Canadian history. Every source opened gives 189. Almost nothing else is stated the same way twice.

Key facts

  • Old Hillcrest Cemetery is 1.45 hectares and was designated a Provincial Historic Resource on February 11, 1985, per the register.
  • The register says 189 miners died in the explosion of June 19, 1914, and that 180 of them were buried in mass graves at the cemetery.
  • The register says 235 workers went underground that morning and that 130 women were widowed.
  • Travel Alberta says a memorial was erected at the cemetery in 2000, as listed on its Hillcrest Mine and Cemetery page.

The Count of Men Underground Depends on the Page

The register says 235 workers descended into the mine that morning. The Wikipedia entry says 237 in its text and 228 in its infobox, without reconciling the two. The figure changes what the rescue means. Subtracting, 237 men underground less 189 dead leaves 48 survivors, which matches the number Wikipedia gives as rescued. The register’s 235 would leave 46.

The families follow the same pattern. The register records 130 widows and 400 fatherless children. Wikipedia gives about 90 widows and about 250 children. Those are not rounding differences. The register’s 130 is about 44% more than 90, in a town of roughly 1,000 people.

The Dead Lie in Mass Graves and the Record Cannot Say How Many

The register says 180 of the miners were buried in mass graves at the cemetery, without giving a number of graves. Travel Alberta and Wikipedia each refer to a single mass grave. The photograph chosen for this page is labelled for a west plot, which suggests at least two. The same arithmetic applies. The register’s 189 dead and 180 in mass graves leave nine men whose burial places the sources do not give. Some may lie elsewhere, and none of the pages says so.

- Advertisement -

The Cause Is Still Reported as Probable

The register describes the likely cause as a spark from falling rock igniting a pocket of methane. Wikipedia says the methane ignition set off a coal dust explosion and that the first spark was never found. Both agree on the gas and the dust. They differ on how confident anyone can be about the ignition, and the register is the more cautious of the two.

Alberta Should Publish One Verified Roll

A disaster this large should not have a crew size that moves between 228, 235 and 237. Wikipedia says the Government of Alberta held an inquiry in 1915, though its own citation dates the report 1914. Alberta’s heritage staff, working from that inquiry and the burial records, should publish a single roll with the count underground, the names of the dead, their ages and the plot each man lies in.

That is archive work, and it is owed to the families who are still counted three ways. The memorial went up in 2000, and the record behind it has not caught up with the stone. For another Crowsnest story where the paperwork thins out, see the piece on the Lille coke ovens and the town that vanished around them, or the Coleman police barracks.

Inside the fence there are two plots, one west and one east, and the concrete stile at the south entrance is the way in.

Related from Alberta Tribune: At 45, West Edmonton Mall Still Cannot Agree on Its Attraction Count

Share This Article
Follow:
Alberta Tribune is an independent Alberta new media and opinion publication based in Calgary. This is the editorial desk byline, used for reporting and commentary produced by the newsroom on Alberta politics, energy and pipelines, business, infrastructure, agriculture, artificial intelligence and provincial public policy.