The Lost Lemon Mine Remains a Legend With No Confirmed Find

Alberta Tribune
Alberta Tribune is an independent Alberta new media and opinion publication based in Calgary. This is the editorial desk byline, used for reporting and commentary produced...
5 Min Read

The legend of the Lost Lemon Mine appeared in the 1946 edition of the Alberta Folklore Quarterly, and it has been retold ever since without a mine at the end of it. The Canadian Encyclopedia dates the supposed discovery to about 1870 and puts the gold somewhere between Crowsnest Pass and the Highwood River.

Illustration for the Lost Lemon Mine legend of southwestern Alberta

Key facts

  • The Canadian Encyclopedia dates the Lost Lemon Mine legend to about 1870 and places the supposed deposit between Crowsnest Pass and the Highwood River in southwestern Alberta.
  • The Canadian Encyclopedia describes the deposit as legendary and lists a single source, the 1968 book The Lost Lemon Mine by D. Riley and others.
  • Wikipedia records that the legend first appeared in the 1946 edition of the Alberta Folklore Quarterly.
  • Historian Hugh Dempsey examined the legend in his book The Lost Lemon Mine: The Greatest Mystery of the Canadian Rockies, according to Wikipedia.

The story rests on a killing and a lost trail

Two prospectors, Frank Lemon and a partner known as Blackjack, are said to have found gold in the winter of 1870. After an argument Lemon killed Blackjack and left for Tobacco Plains, Montana. When he later tried to guide others back, he could not find the place.

That is the whole of it, and every telling since has been built on those few events. The Canadian Encyclopedia entry rests on one book, published nearly a century after the supposed discovery.

Searchers have found a story and nothing else

The same entry says the search has drawn thousands of seekers over the years. It reports no confirmed find. Our arithmetic puts the legend at roughly 156 years old, counting from 1870, and in that time the record has added searches without adding a location.

The country the legend names runs from Crowsnest Pass to the Highwood River, and what survives from it on paper is the story, the 1946 folklore article and the 1968 book.

- Advertisement -

Updated October 7, 2026. The earlier version called Dan Riley a former High River mayor and legislator, said Montana newspapers and historical records confirmed Frank Lemon, and described modern satellite imaging of the area. None of those claims could be verified and all are removed.

Related from Alberta Tribune: Norquay’s Century of Skiing Hangs on a Lift First Built in 1948 · Turner Valley and the First Oil Boom That Built Modern Alberta · Calgary’s Black Squirrels Have A Story And No Paperwork

Share This Article
Follow:
Alberta Tribune is an independent Alberta new media and opinion publication based in Calgary. This is the editorial desk byline, used for reporting and commentary produced by the newsroom on Alberta politics, energy and pipelines, business, infrastructure, agriculture, artificial intelligence and provincial public policy.