The Toll Math Behind Alberta’s Proposed West Coast Pipeline

Alberta Tribune
Alberta Tribune is an independent Alberta new media and opinion publication based in Calgary. This is the editorial desk byline, used for reporting and commentary produced...
7 Min Read

$18.70 a barrel. That is the initial fixed toll the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis puts on Alberta’s proposed West Coast oil pipeline in 2032 under its cheaper scenario, rising to $23.72 a barrel by 2034 under the expensive one. Against a 2013 Trans Mountain contracted toll of $3.60 to $3.90 a barrel, that is roughly five times the number in nominal dollars, which is the Tribune’s own arithmetic on their figures. The report was published on 1 September 2026 and the toll section is the part of it that deserves an answer.

Key facts

  • The Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis published its assessment of the proposed West Coast oil pipeline on 1 September 2026, using the Government of Alberta’s capital cost range of $35.2 billion to $43.7 billion.
  • That assessment models an initial fixed toll of $18.70 a barrel in 2032 under its low-cost case and $23.72 a barrel in 2034 under its high-cost case, and puts the resulting cost to producers at $2.2 billion to $3.2 billion a year over 20 years.
  • The International Energy Agency World Energy Outlook 2025, published 12 November 2025, shows global oil demand rising to 113 million barrels a day by 2050 without peaking, in its Current Policies Scenario.
  • The Government of Alberta says it has spent $18.3 million planning the project so far.
  • The project was referred to the federal Major Projects Office on 2 July 2026 and, per that office’s page, was listed under Schedule 1 of the Building Canada Act on 1 October 2026.

A toll is a permanent deduction from the netback

The mechanism gets skipped. A producer sells a barrel at a reference price, then subtracts what it costs to move that barrel to the buyer, and what is left is the netback. A pipeline toll is not a fee the producer pays out of profit at year end. It comes off every barrel, every day, for the twenty or thirty years the contract runs, and it is set to recover the capital cost of the line whether or not the line is full.

That is why capital cost and toll are the same conversation. A line costing $35.2 billion and a line costing $43.7 billion are not two versions of the same project. They are two different deductions from every barrel in the basin that ships on it, and the difference between them is roughly $5 a barrel in the modelled tolls. Nobody in this industry should wave that off, and the people who dismiss the report because of who wrote it are dismissing the one piece of arithmetic the proponents have not published themselves.

The demand argument uses one scenario and calls it the forecast

The report’s supporting claim is that global oil demand growth falls to zero around 2030, before the pipe would ever run. That claim rests on the International Energy Agency’s Stated Policies Scenario. The same agency, in the same publication, on the same day, also publishes a Current Policies Scenario in which demand climbs to 113 million barrels a day by 2050 and does not peak at all. World Energy Outlook 2025 was released on 12 November 2025 and contains both.

A scenario is an input somebody selected. It is not a finding. Anybody writing about this project, on either side, who says the International Energy Agency expects demand to peak in 2030 has chosen a scenario and hidden the choice. Name the scenario or do not use the number.

- Advertisement -

The toll argument does not depend on that choice, which is why it survives the criticism and the demand argument does not. Even if demand keeps climbing, a producer still pays $18.70 a barrel to move oil through a line that costs $35 billion to build. Volume does not fix a toll. Volume is what the toll is charged on.

The competing toll estimates do not agree with each other either

An independent analysis published on 4 August 2026 by the Macdonald-Laurier Institute runs the same problem and calculates a toll of roughly $11.80 to $14.30 a barrel to recover the announced cost, against a market-clearing toll near $11. It puts the capital cost at $60 billion to $100 billion on the overrun history of Trans Mountain’s expansion, and estimates that the legacy line cross-subsidizes the expansion by roughly $4.70 a barrel. Two analyses, two toll ranges, no agreement. Attribute each figure to the document it came from and never average them, because they are built on different capital assumptions and different allocations.

What Alberta has actually spent so far is $18.3 million on planning, which buys a case rather than a pipeline. The named partners include Trans Mountain Corporation and Pembina Pipeline Corporation, and also the Alberta Petroleum Marketing Commission, which is a provincial Crown agency and not a private partner, a distinction worth keeping straight when anybody describes the ownership structure. The file was referred to the Major Projects Office on 2 July 2026 and listed under Schedule 1 of the Building Canada Act on 1 October 2026, after this column first ran.

This province has been told before that a line was not needed, and that advice aged badly for everyone who took it. That history is a reason to build, not a reason to skip the toll arithmetic. Smaller producers in particular need the tolling structure argued out loud now, while the capital estimate is still a range and not a contract, because a fixed toll signed in 2032 cannot be renegotiated in 2040.

Listing settles the federal pathway and leaves the toll question where it was. Watch the Major Projects Office page, not the press releases.

Related from Alberta Tribune: Nine Shippers And Twenty Years Decide Which Pipeline Gets Built

Share This Article
Follow:
Alberta Tribune is an independent Alberta new media and opinion publication based in Calgary. This is the editorial desk byline, used for reporting and commentary produced by the newsroom on Alberta politics, energy and pipelines, business, infrastructure, agriculture, artificial intelligence and provincial public policy.