Governments Say They Want Affordable Housing. Then They Tax It Like Crazy.

Shane Wenzel
6 Min Read

Every government in Canada says it wants more affordable housing. You hear it from city councils, provincial leaders and federal politicians. They all know the lines by now. We need more supply. We need faster approvals. We need homes young people can actually afford. That all sounds good, but then the same governments turn around and add massive charges to every new home before a family ever gets the keys.

Development charges started with a reasonable idea. If a new community needs roads, pipes, sidewalks, parks, drainage and other infrastructure, growth should help pay for that growth. Most people can understand that. Builders understand it too. Nobody is pretending infrastructure is free, and nobody is saying municipalities should be left holding the bag when new communities are built.

The problem is that development charges have become much bigger than their original purpose. Too many governments now treat them like a cash cow. They load costs onto new homes because it is politically easier than raising property taxes or having an honest conversation about municipal spending. The builder may write the cheque upfront, but the buyer pays for it in the final price. That means young families, first-time buyers, newcomers and renters trying to move up are the ones carrying the burden.

This is where the whole argument starts to fall apart. Politicians say they want affordability, but they keep adding costs to the very housing they claim they want built. In some markets, development charges and other government fees can add tens of thousands of dollars, and sometimes much more, to the cost of a new home. That money does not disappear. It gets baked into the price, financed through a mortgage, and paid back with interest by the homeowner over many years.

There is also a fairness issue here. A lot of infrastructure funded through these charges does not only benefit the people buying new homes. Roads, recreation centres, parks, water systems and other municipal services often benefit the broader community. If everyone benefits, then everyone should carry a fair share of the cost. It makes no sense to put the heaviest burden on the next generation of buyers simply because they are easier to tax and not yet living in the municipality.

- Advertisement -

The result is predictable. Projects become harder to make work. Builders delay or cancel housing. Buyers are pushed out of the market. Supply falls further behind demand. Then governments hold another press conference about the housing crisis, as if they had nothing to do with creating the conditions that made housing more expensive in the first place.

There are better ways to handle this. Municipalities should limit development charges to infrastructure that is directly tied to new growth, and they should be fully transparent about where the money goes. If a charge is being collected for a road, pipe or facility, residents should be able to see the cost, the timeline and the reason for it. No more vague buckets. No more using new homebuyers to quietly fund wish lists.

Cities should also finance long-term infrastructure over the life of the asset. If a water line, bridge or road is going to serve a community for 30 or 40 years, it makes sense to pay for it over time instead of forcing the full cost onto the first buyer. That is how households and businesses think about long-term investments, and governments should not be afraid to use the same common sense.

Some costs should be spread through the broader property tax base, especially when the infrastructure benefits the entire community. This may not be politically convenient, but it is more honest. Existing homeowners benefit from growing communities too. They benefit from better roads, stronger local businesses, expanded services and rising property values. They should not be completely shielded while new buyers are asked to carry the whole load.

Provincial and federal governments also need to step up with infrastructure funding that is tied to real housing outcomes. Money should flow to municipalities that approve homes faster, reduce unnecessary fees and actually get shovels in the ground. If cities block housing, delay projects or pile on costs, they should not be rewarded with blank cheques.

User fees can also play a role where they make sense. Water, wastewater and certain services can be paid for based on usage instead of being front-loaded into the price of a home. Land value capture is another option, especially around major transit or infrastructure investments where public spending increases nearby land values. The point is not that one tool solves everything. The point is that development charges should not be the easy answer to every municipal budget problem.

Canada will not fix housing affordability if governments keep treating new homes like revenue machines. We need infrastructure, but we also need honesty about who pays and why. Growth should help build communities, not become an excuse to tax the next generation out of home ownership. If governments are serious about affordability, they need to stop punishing the very housing they say they want.

Share This Article