The tax cut the Liberals could never copy

Shane Wenzel
7 Min Read

If the Conservatives want one plank that separates them from everybody else in Ottawa, it is this. Let Canadians keep the first $100,000 they earn, and shrink the government that has been taking it.

I have spent more than thirty years in this business and not once has an employee or a buyer asked me about the page count of the Income Tax Act. Kim Moody, a friend of mine, is right that the Act is a mess and I would hand him the pen tomorrow. But the argument at the kitchen table is simpler than that.

How much is left?

This year the Fraser Institute figures the average Canadian family will earn $166,790 and pay $72,539 of it in taxes at every level of government. That is 43.5 cents of every dollar. A family works until June 9 before the money starts belonging to them, and then we wonder why young people cannot put together a down payment.

I am not against government. I want the roads plowed, the water treated, and permits processed by somebody who answers the phone.

- Advertisement -

That is where I have a problem. The size of the bite has become the problem itself, and tinkering with brackets does not touch it.

One idea in front of the party right now would change the arithmetic. Build Canada published a memo in June proposing that Ottawa raise the amount you can earn before it takes anything, from about $16,000 to $100,000. Around 88% of filers earn less than that, so for nearly nine out of ten Canadians federal income tax would simply end. A teacher on $65,000 keeps about $7,000 a year. A tradesperson earning the same keeps about $8,500.

Think about what that is in a real house. That is a down payment two or three years sooner. That is the second kid people keep telling me they cannot afford. That is the guy who has talked for years about starting his own crew finally buying the truck.

Melissa Lantsman wrote about it on her Substack in July and noted that it is not party policy. It should be.

Now the hard part. A cut that size gives up something like $130 to $140 billion a year, and it does nothing about the debt we have already run up. On Ottawa’s own projections, interest alone will swallow one of every eight dollars of federal revenue by 2029. No tax cut fixes that. Only a smaller government does, and the same memo finds about $35 billion a year in a line-by-line review of federal spending, which tells me the money is there when somebody wants to find it.

This is where our side has been too timid. Conservatism was never a set of tax rates. It is the belief that a government should live inside its means the way the rest of us do. In my business, when revenue falls you cut, you consolidate, and you explain it to your people. You do not borrow forever and call it an investment.

Here is why this belongs on the front page of a platform instead of buried in the back. A rate cut can be copied, and the Liberals proved it when they trimmed the bottom bracket to 14%. A plan that only pays out as Ottawa gets smaller cannot be copied by a party whose every instinct is to grow it. They can attack it. They cannot match it. Then we are finally having the argument conservatives should want, which is who should be trusted with the first hundred thousand dollars of a family’s work.

I want to come back to Kim, because he has carried this fight longer than most people have been paying attention. He built Moodys Tax here in Calgary, chaired the Canadian Tax Foundation and STEP Canada, writes in the Financial Post most weeks, and wrote a book called Making Life Less Taxing for people who are never going to read a statute. For more than a dozen years he has asked Ottawa for one honest review of how this country taxes, something we have not attempted since a royal commission was appointed in 1962. The Act has grown past 2,800 pages and it is now incomprehensible even to the professionals who spend their careers inside it.

Every year he makes that case, Ottawa answers by adding pages.

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

So here is the part I think Kim would enjoy. Take most Canadians off the federal tax rolls and the machinery built to check credits and claw back benefits has nothing left to do. Real simplification, without anybody redrafting one of those 2,800 pages.

If I were writing this plank, it would be three lines and no fine print.

First, name the number. One hundred thousand as the destination, thirty thousand in year one, so people feel it before they are asked to believe in it.

Second, say out loud what gets cut to pay for it. A party that will not name the programs is not serious.

Third, tie every step to savings that have actually landed. Find the money faster and the cut arrives faster.

My position is simple. Take less. Spend less. Then get out of the way and let people build.

We are builders of a better future, not politicians. Hand Canadians back the reward for their own work and they will do more with it than any program has.

Share This Article