Alberta Farms Earned $591 Million More And Collected Far Less

Alberta Tribune
Alberta Tribune is an independent Alberta news and opinion publication based in Calgary. This is the editorial desk byline, used for reporting and commentary produced by...
5 Min Read

Alberta farms took in $591.2 million more in the first half of this year than they did a year earlier. That was the second largest provincial gain in the country, behind Saskatchewan at $744.5 million.

The national number from Statistics Canada is $51.8 billion in farm cash receipts for January through June, up 4.2%. On its own that reads as a good half year. The composition underneath it is the more interesting document, because the money came from a different place than it used to.

Cattle prices did the heavy lifting

Livestock receipts hit $23.2 billion, up 8.7%. Cattle alone added $1.1 billion, and the way it happened is worth pulling apart. Prices were up 17.7%. Marketings were down 3.8%.

Producers sold fewer animals for considerably more money. That is a herd rebuilding signal as much as a price signal, and it means the receipts figure is not describing a bigger industry. It is describing a tighter one with better terms.

- Advertisement -

Crops came in at $27.1 billion, up 4.1%. Canola contributed $1.3 billion of that, and this time the mechanics ran the other way. Marketings were up 15.6% and prices up 4.6%. More volume moved, at modestly better prices, into a market that spent the first half of the year reopening.

The line that fell off a cliff

Direct government payments dropped $828.0 million, a decline of 35.5%, landing at $1.5 billion.

More than 80% of that decline is one line item. Crop insurance payouts fell $680.2 million. The Prairie provinces account for $812.5 million of the total crop insurance reduction, which tells you where the drought years were and where they were not.

Read plainly, that is the system working. Crop insurance is supposed to pay out when crops fail and shrink when they do not. A big decline in indemnities after better growing conditions is the correct outcome, not a policy failure.

Why the composition matters more than the total

Here is the sentence worth keeping. Alberta farms earned more from the market and collected far less from the government, and the market money more than covered the difference.

- Advertisement -

That is the version of a farm economy anybody who works in one actually wants. Program payments are a floor, not a business model, and every producer knows the difference between a cheque that arrives because prices were good and a cheque that arrives because the crop burned.

It also changes how the next round of program debates should be read. When support payments fall by a third in a single year, the political temptation is to describe it as abandonment. The numbers do not support that reading. Receipts went up while support went down, which means the sector absorbed the reduction on the strength of its own sales.

Two caveats before anyone declares victory

The first is that these are receipts, not margins. Gross revenue rose. Nothing in this release says what fertilizer, fuel, interest, feed or equipment did to the other side of the ledger, and producers will tell you the input line has not been generous.

The second is that the half year ends in June. Alberta’s wet season arrived after that, and the province has already extended the AgriStability deadline in response. A first half built on good conditions does not describe what the combines are finding right now.

So take the figures for what they are. Alberta agriculture had a strong first half, earned it in the market rather than at the program window, and did it while the safety net was paying out a third less than the year before. That is a sector standing on its own feet.

- Advertisement -

Whether it is still standing on them when the second half numbers land is a separate question, and it will be answered by weather rather than by policy.

Would you rather see farm income come from stronger markets or from steadier programs?

Share This Article
Follow:
Alberta Tribune is an independent Alberta news and opinion publication based in Calgary. This is the editorial desk byline, used for reporting and commentary produced by the newsroom on Alberta politics, energy and pipelines, business, infrastructure, agriculture, artificial intelligence and provincial public policy.
Leave a Comment